Secretary of State Tucker Carlson draws more criticism

LEAVING aside the straw man – Carlson hasn’t advocated Hungarianisation – it’s genuinely tragic to see a conservative/libertarian defence of America so shot through with denialism about what the country has become under a dictatorship of left-wing relativism. If Orbán is an illiberal dictator – rather than, say, a nationalist as jealous of Hungary’s culture as Daniel Andrews is of a ‘safe’ picnic – he differs from Joe Biden only insofar as he’s in charge. When the chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff works for the Chinese Communist Party (and is celebrated for it), state powers are no longer separated the way they used to be.

Hungary’s Orbán is the champion of what he has dubbed “illiberal democracy.” This form of government is characterized by an explicit support of nativist Christian policy enacted through authoritarian measures. Yet conservatives who place their hopes in this philosophy are misguided. Disregarding the fact that recreating the U.S. in the image of Hungary is practically impossible, this notion misses the entire point of the American experiment.

While you could technically call Hungary a democracy, it lacks basic protections and separation of power which we take for granted in the U.S. Orbán has consolidated power over the three branches of government within his party, Fidesz. He controls large swaths of the press. The economy is also an expression of cronyism, with valuable grants awarded to the party faithful. He has also used the courts to punish rival political parties.

The root of Hungary’s appeal to American conservatives is that Orbán has successfully countered progressive ideas and laws in the country. Essentially, some conservatives are willing to give up freedoms in order to counter what they see as the ascendant progressive project.

The concluding argument is interesting as a challenge. Are there freedoms that Brexiteers, Trump fans, “blue tide” Latin Americans or their 11 or so Australian equivalents want to “give up” to beat leftism? I can’t think of any. To play any sort of meaningful role in saving liberty, libertarians have to stop begging the big questions. Controlling borders and the ethnic/religious make-up of a nation is not giving up a freedom. Nor is free speech. Nor is re-empowering traditional families, marriage, schools, Judeo-Christian culture, the Western canon, businesses, markets or private associations. The ‘freedom’ cherished by the left is the unchallenged one to go on laying waste to all these things, all these people. This is not freedom to give up but viciousness to root out.

This entry was posted in International. Bookmark the permalink.

7 Responses to Secretary of State Tucker Carlson draws more criticism

  1. Not Trampis says:

    Carlson is typical of people supporting the reactionary right. Not much intellect at all.
    Orban is merely showing what Trump wanted to do. Destroy institutions and you destroy democracy.
    Trumpists and their ilk don’t like democracy. They want to subvert it and remain in power forever.
    Nativist Christian values is a contradiction in terms.
    Nor does he like trump believe in markets. authoritarians never do.

  2. C.L. says:

    You need to identify what institutions Orban is destroying.

  3. rosie says:

    I’d like to know that too.
    He seems to be strengthening institutions like marriage and the family.

  4. Lee says:

    Not Trampis says:
    17 September, 2021 at 9:17 am

    Bullshit from start to finish.

  5. Not Trampis says:

    you are kidding aren’t you. The courts for a start. Funny how many of the opposition are charged.
    It is impossible to have free and fair elections there for another.

  6. dover_beach says:

    Orbán’s Hungary is most Western democracies until the 2000s. But let us be even more clear, critics of Orbán pretend that they are aghast at the style and form of his government when in fact what offends them is the substance. It’s his defense of Hungary as a Christian nation, his promotion of the family, and the like, that riles them. They have no scruples at all when power is wielded is to ‘liberal’ ends, but they scream like stuck pigs when that same power is wielded to traditional ends. Get used to it. We see you. We don’t care.

  7. Not Trampis says:

    only the biblically illiterate would call any country a Christian nation.

    Please note no defence against the undermining of the courts or other institutions. It is all good!

    why do Trumpists like wanna be dictators so much.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *